Stevia vs. Aspartame: Unpacking the Sweeteners

The quest for sweetness without the sugar high is a common one, and the market is brimming with sugar substitutes. Among the most popular contenders are stevia and aspartame. While both offer calorie reduction compared to traditional sugar, they differ significantly in their origins, production, and the ongoing scientific discussions surrounding their safety. At Pyure, as a maker of organic plant-based stevia sweeteners, we believe in empowering you with knowledge to make informed choices about what you consume. Let's delve into the world of stevia and aspartame to understand the key distinctions. 

Stevia: Nature's Sweet Secret 

Stevia is derived from the leaves of the Stevia rebaudiana plant, native to South America. For centuries, the indigenous Guaraní people of Paraguay have used the leaves for sweetness and medicinal properties. The sweet compounds in stevia are called steviol glycosides, with Rebaudioside A (Reb A) being the most common and commercially used. 

Related: Reb A, Reb M, and Reb D Explained 

• Plant Origin: Stevia is a plant-based sweetener. Steviol glycosides are extracted from stevia leaves using a process that may vary by manufacturer, but always begins with the plant itself. Pyure, in particular, focuses on organic stevia, ensuring our plants are grown and processed without synthetic pesticides or fertilizers.
• Zero Calories & Zero Glycemic Impact: Stevia offers sweetness without adding calories and has little to no impact on blood sugar levels and glycemic index, making it a popular choice for individuals managing their weight, sugar withdrawal, or blood glucose.
• Generally Recognized As Safe (GRAS): The U.S. Food and Drug Administration (FDA) has given high-purity steviol glycoside extracts GRAS status, meaning they are considered safe for consumption under intended conditions of use. Regulatory bodies around the world also approve stevia for use.
• Long History of Use: As mentioned, stevia has a long history of traditional use, offering a level of comfort and familiarity that synthetic alternatives lack. Various forms are available including stevia packets, granular, and liquid stevia.
• Flavor Profile: While generally sweet, some individuals may detect a slight licorice-like aftertaste with certain stevia products. Advancements in extraction and blending have significantly improved the flavor profile of high-quality stevia. 

Aspartame: A Synthetic Sweetener 

Aspartame is an artificial, or synthetic, sweetener. It's a dipeptide composed of two amino acids: aspartic acid and phenylalanine. It was accidentally discovered in 1965 and approved for use in food products in the early 1980s. 

Aspartame consumption, whether within recommended safe levels or at higher levels, may disrupt oxidant/antioxidant balance, induce oxidative stress, and damage cell membrane integrity, potentially leading to systemic inflammation.

• Synthetic Origin: Unlike stevia, aspartame is created in a laboratory through a chemical process. It is not derived from a natural plant source.
• Low Calorie: While not entirely calorie-free, aspartame is significantly lower in calories than sugar, offering around 4 calories per gram compared to sugar's 16. However, because it is much sweeter than sugar, only tiny amounts are needed, resulting in negligible calorie intake in practical use.
• FDA Approved, But with Ongoing Scrutiny: Aspartame is approved by the FDA and many other regulatory bodies worldwide. However, its approval has been a subject of ongoing debate and scientific scrutiny for decades.
• Phenylketonuria (PKU) Warning: Individuals with the rare genetic disorder phenylketonuria (PKU) cannot metabolize phenylalanine, a component of aspartame. Products containing aspartame are required to carry a warning for individuals with PKU.
• Concerns and Controversies: Aspartame has been the subject of numerous studies and controversies over the years, with some research suggesting potential links to various health issues. While regulatory bodies generally maintain its safety at approved levels, these concerns persist for many consumers and some within the scientific community. 

Due to these concerns, retailers such as Whole Foods, have taken the step of banning aspartame from their shelves. 

Read further: Breaking Down Aspartame: Is it bad for you? 

Stevia vs. Aspartame: The Key Differences 

Here's a side-by-side comparison to highlight the core differences: 

Why Choose Stevia (and Why Pyure)? 

At Pyure, our commitment to providing organic, plant-based stevia stems from our belief in the power of nature and a desire to offer a sweetener option we feel good about.

• Closer to Nature: We believe in choosing ingredients that are close to their original state. Stevia, originating from a plant, aligns with this philosophy.
• Transparency and Trust: We prioritize transparency in our sourcing and production processes, offering consumers a product they can trust. Our organic certification is a testament to this commitment.
• Avoiding Synthetic Additives: We prefer to avoid synthetic ingredients like aspartame, which have been the subject of persistent health concerns and regulatory debates.
• Supporting a Wellness Lifestyle: For those seeking a sweet option without the calories and glycemic impact of sugar, and who prefer a plant-based alternative, stevia is a compelling choice. 

Making Your Sweet Choice 

Ultimately, the choice between stevia and aspartame is a personal one. However, understanding the fundamental differences in their origins, production, and the ongoing scientific discussions is crucial for making an informed decision that aligns with your health goals and values. 

For those seeking an organic, and plant-based sweetener with a long history of safe use, stevia – particularly organic options like Pyure– presents a compelling alternative to synthetic sweeteners like aspartame. We encourage you to explore the world of stevia and experience the sweetness that nature intended. 

Read Next: Stevia vs Allulose